Useful? Share it!

Girls’ school uniforms – let them wear shorts and pants

Girls wearning skirt as part of the school uniformEver had that moment when your child decides to dress themselves completely inappropriately for some occasion? It happened to me when my daughter was three, and she put on what was essentially a ball gown for a park play date.

Once at the park, the ball gown became a nightmare. She kept tripping over it while running around, and when she tried to climb the spiderweb she would stand on her dress and come perilously close to toppling off the structure.

From that day on, I have dressed my daughter in shorts or pants when we are doing anything active. At a certain age, you figure out that particular clothing types are more appropriate for some activities than others. That’s why you don’t see an adult doing a workout in high heels, or children playing soccer in dresses.

What about the practicalities of school uniforms?

When my daughter enrolled at our local public school, I was dismayed to see that from Grade 1, she would be expected to wear a dress to school. How would she play at lunchtime in a dress? Wouldn’t she be cold in winter with just tights on her legs? When I raised these issues with the school, I was told that girls look nice in dresses and like to wear them. When I continued to resist and pressed for change, asking the school to add shorts and pants for girls, I was ostracised and silenced.

I remain perplexed by the school’s insistence that their female students, from five years old, must attend in dresses. What messages are we sending girls when we require them to wear dresses and skirts to school? Are we encouraging them to sit still and be passive? Are we prioritising tradition and gender norms over the needs of school girls? Largely we are, and it’s time we acknowledge that this needs to change.

Does the type of uniform matter?

Research shows that girls wearing dresses to school directly results in girls doing less physical activity.

In one Australian study in 2012, researchers used pedometers to record the number of steps undertaken by primary school girls and boys over a one-month period. For two weeks the students wore their formal uniform (dress for girls, shorts for boys), and for two weeks they wore their sports uniform (shorts for both genders). The results showed that only the girls’ physical activity levels were affected by the type of uniform they wore, with girls doing significantly less exercise when wearing a dress than when wearing the shorts.

In two recent Australian studies, 10 to 13-year-old school children were asked what factors they felt impacted on their ability to engage in lunchtime play. The girls reported that their uniform significantly restricted their ability to play at lunchtime (boys did not mention their uniform). The researchers highlighted that most girls acknowledged the restrictive nature of dresses and skirts, and felt that they would be more physically active if their clothing allowed it. In addition, the girls noted the gendered nature of the school uniform, which made it easier for boys to be active.

While girls are telling us that their uniform gets in the way of them being active, we also have data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics clearly showing that girls are significantly less physically active than boys, and that this inaction kicks in right around the time they start high school. Coincidentally, this is exactly when girls often move from a primary school that is likely to have allowed them to wear shorts (or skorts) and pants, to a high school that is likely not to.

Let common sense prevail

All of us know that if we want to be active, if we are going to run around and jump, twirl, skid and slide, we are going to be far more comfortable and far more capable in shorts or pants than in any other attire.

As the Federal government continues to pour taxpayer money into national education programs aimed at getting girls moving, including $7 million added to the Girls Make Your Move campaign this year, surely it is time we reconsider the most basic aspect of what allows us to be active – our clothing?

If you would like to support girls across the country have greater options in their everyday school uniform, visit the Girls’ Uniform Agenda Facebook page and website. There you will find resources you can use to add your voice to this fight, including by signing our petition.

This issue does not have to be complex, and with enough pressure from parents across the country, we can get this done. We know how to get girls playing more soccer at school, and it’s free; let them wear shorts and pants!

Post your comment

Comment Guidelines : Play nice! We welcome opinions, discussion and compliments. Especially compliments. But remember: the person on the other side of the computer screen is someone's mum, brother, nan or highly intelligent but opinionated cat. We don't tolerate nastiness or bullying. We'll delete disrespectful comments and any replies to them. more

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

If you have a Gravatar, it will appear next to your comments. Read more about Gravatars here

*

Prove you're human ... *

4 comments so far -

  1. Our school has a dress for ‘formal days’, a sports day outfit, as well as a skort/culotte option.
    This would mean that if we wanted our girls to have the short option we would have to buty the ‘third’ uniform, as the sports and formal dress were mandatory.

    Myself and one other mum had a meeting with our principal to request that the skort option be made the mandatory ‘formal’ outfit (it looks as smart as the boys 2-piece), and that the dress be made the ‘optional extra’.

    The initial meeting went so well, the principal completely agreed, said he had no problem with it, and didn’t even need a case to be made. But there was another meeting scheduled as we needed to discuss the length of the short with the uniform shop manager.

    Second meeting we just get bluntly told ‘I spoke to the teachers and some students and the dress is very popular and looks much better’…. so no change allowed.

    Days after the meeting, my child (6 years old) was told not to do handstands, cartwheels or monkey bars due to inappropriate underwear (only came up because I asked her why on earth she was putting on thick winter tights on a 30degree day).

    I have sent a very direct email to state the inequality, impracticality as well as the disadvantage that this has on our girls. That they should focus on being smart, not looking smart. Not to mention the obsession in society wear appearance trumps substance.
    Response received was that I was accused of not caring that a school should look neat, smart and presentable…!!
    Oh, and that the monkey bar thing was a health and safety thing about not being upside-down…. (so explain to me if it wasn’t about underwear then why was she going to cover herself if thick tights??)
    Oh – and adults are responsible for the messages our children receive… ( an so this dissolves a schools responsibility on the matter).

    Nothing truer than people don’t like change. It’s sooooo scary.
    **bashing my head on desk***

    • OMG. Thanks for sharing this experience with us, Lion. How disappointing – especially given the fact that, at first, the principal seemed to see sense on the issue. How completely frustrating. I can understand the feeling of wanting to bash your head on the desk!

      Let’s hope that little by little this begins to change! I am grateful that my child’s school has both options for girls but I don’t think I’ll find the same attitude in the high schools. Maybe by then… we can only hope.

      Take care x

FEATURED SUPPORTER
Baby SensoryBaby Sensory is the only baby programme that offers a complete approach to learning & development. Our classes ...
FORUMS - chatting now ...
Spectacular September TTCConception & Fertility General Chat
Who has their partner on Menevit?Conception issues & ttc
The Bachelor 2017 - Matty JMovies / Music / Books / TV Chat
Hyundai i30 (new model) boot sizeProduct Recommendations & Questions
Optimistic October TTCConception & Fertility General Chat
REVIEWS
"Made bed time less anxious"
by Meld85
My Little Heart Whisbear - the Humming Bear reviews ›
"Wonderful natural Aussie made product!"
by Mrstwr
Baby U Goat Milk Moisturiser reviews ›
"Replaced good quality with cheap tight nappies"
by Kris
Coles Comfy Bots Nappies reviews ›
back to top