I saw this Michael Moore tidbit in my newsfeed and it's made me curious how parents feel about homework? Shorter school hours? Shorter school years?
My DH is completely against homework and has said he won't force our kids to do it. I hope this doesn't hurt them at school. The principal at our DS's school told us that homework isn't compulsory so I'm hoping he won't be in trouble if he doesn't do it (of course if he wants to do homework, we will encourage and help him, but DH is adamant that home time is for playing, doing sport or other extra curricular, or for spending time with family).
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 58
21-08-2016 20:33 #1
What are your thoughts about homework?
The Following User Says Thank You to witherwings For This Useful Post:
21-08-2016 21:15 #2
DS is only in kindy and we don't get homework yet ( just home readers) so I'm a bit torn on homework - I don't think their should be excessive homework in primary school ( reading I think is important) but in regards to the Michael Moore doco if you look at the latest rankings , Finland is falling in the ranking quite a lot and lost its top spot ( and their economy is one of the worst in Europe) and the top 5 countries in the world for maths and reading now are Asian countries who do do longer school hours and more homework so I'm not sure yet where I stand! I'm guessing in high school it is a lot more important
The Following User Says Thank You to Elijahs Mum For This Useful Post:
21-08-2016 21:20 #3
I guess kids needs to get used to homework before they start high school otherwise they will really struggle. I personally enjoyed doing homework when I was in primary school and loved reading too. I hope my boys are like me and less like DH! Lol
21-08-2016 21:34 #4
I have DD1 in year 3 and DD2 in her first year of school.
DD1 blazes through her homework for the week straight after school on a monday so its done.
She reads for enjoyment and as a wind down each evening for 30-45minutes.
DD2 needs supervision and help with her homework so we grab 5mins here, 10mins there throughout the week between me & DH and thats plenty of time to get her homework done. She gets read to along with DS each night before bed.
We dont make a huge deal out or stress about homework but we do ensure its done
The Following User Says Thank You to RmumR For This Useful Post:
21-08-2016 21:57 #5
I am not a fan of homework at all! The only homework that should be done is reading. In our house reading is done everyday and a book is taken everywhere.
From my reading the benefits of homework are not there until well into high school.
DD12 is in year 6 and this week has her homework which is 20 spelling words, 2 homework sheets, 20mins reading and whatever maths comes home tomorrow. She was also given last week a history assignment due in a week and an oral presentation on a song (and its video) about social issues.
DD9 is in year 3 and has to write a complex sentence with big words each day, write out times-tables and their turn around, some other maths questions. She also has studyladder activities and read theory website activities.
I got annoyed with DD9 teacher as she was not coping and it was so hard to get DDs homework reduced. I am now over it. She gets done what she gets done, I'm not going to push anymore. Her crying and getting frustrated does not help her learning.
So, after my DDs going through this much schooling I have hit the I don't care about homework stage. I am not going to pressure or force them to do it. If the homework that was set was realistic (time wise) then that would be different.
21-08-2016 22:49 #6
This is my concern - unfair expectations of young children. If it's not compulsory then at least it takes the pressure off. I'm glad that's the policy in DS's school. The principal said they wanted to get rid of homework all together but too many parents complained.
21-08-2016 23:30 #7
My kids are not in school yet but I don't totally like the idea of homework.
When you are in school, you are told not to talk and play around yet when you go home, you are expected to do a lot of homework.... So when do you get to chat and play with your friends/family?! for this reason I hate homework.
Someone once explained to me that homework was given so children can show that they learnt something in class and can remember it and put it into practice. Gives them a chance in their own time to have a go without the pressure of peers around. So for that theory I don't mind homework. But I think it should be relevant to the kids and just a few quick questions that don't take much time.
Or tasks/assignments could be done in real life situations.
Eg: adding up a shopping list/working out change,
Measuring ingredients for a recipe. Etc
The Following User Says Thank You to almai For This Useful Post:
22-08-2016 04:23 #8
My children don't have much homework. My daughter in year 2 gets a small amount. My son who started school this year gets home readers only. As a parent I hate homework. As a teacher I hate homework but often parents demand it.
Although Finland has fallen to 6th place, I would much rather their model than the top Asian countries where school hours are long, plus crammed after school tuition and high suicide rates. They might now top the education rankings but they're certainly not developing rounded students; they're all just robots with no time for anything else.
22-08-2016 04:47 #9Senior Member
- Join Date
- May 2014
We don't participate in homework until year 5. I tell teachers we don't do homework, and I tell teachers my child isn't to be punished for not doing homework.
In saying that, we do keep an eye on our kids and work closely with their teacher to ensure they're not falling behind.
We do plenty of things at home that enable the kids to learn in a fun way....we do readers until they are up to a decent level, and then switch to more exciting books at home. We play hangman, have spelling bees in the car, post letters to their friends etc. etc.
From year 5, we encourage homework as preparation for highschool, as we know they have to do homework in highschool. We also participate in projects in the early school years.
Our kids haven't been disadvantaged in any way with this approach, and it saves a lot of fights and stress from tired kids who are just done for the day.
22-08-2016 06:07 #10
GymbaROOGymbaROO offers activities for babies & toddlers in a fun learning centre, focussing on developmental education. ...
LATESTToilet training: when is the best time to start?Why it is OK for your child to be differentWhat is a blessing way? How is it different to a baby shower?
POPULARWhen can I start giving chores to my children?New baby nursery checklist – a guide to newborn essentialsWhat to pack for labour and hospital – a checklist
FORUMS - chatting now ...
HGC lelvels stressed please helpConception & Fertility General Chat
IVF babies due Sep/Oct/Nov 2017pregnancy and babies through IVF
Early waking/routine help 17 month oldToddlers (1 year olds)
Situations - ok or not ok?General Parenting Tips, Advice & Chat
Nub gender guess for fun !Second Trimester Chat
Feature film callout to expecting mothers - melbourneMedia Requests
Cyclone Debbie Support thread.General Chat