All three of my girls are/had happy dispositions and still showed alarm when other people held or hold them. (my other daughters are older now. )
+ Reply to Thread
Results 11 to 20 of 30
01-08-2016 14:40 #11
Last edited by Marchbundle; 01-08-2016 at 14:44.
01-08-2016 15:06 #12
Just now as she was leaving he started screaming as she was holding him and she said, "he's probably hungry, maybe your breastmilk isn't enough for him anymore." Arghhhhhh! Sorry just had to vent. Thanks everyone, I feel better now.
01-08-2016 16:20 #13
Argh MILs!!! Nod, smile and NEVER doubt that you know your baby best!
I have 2 kids. They are 17 months apart and are both currently toddlers. Although I try to parent them the same it is obvious that their early life experiences have been very different and yes I have seen that it's affected their personality. So my oldest has had my undivided attention from the moment he was born. We are very connected emotionally. We both love cuddling and could easily be in physical contact with each other all day. He always wants to play WITH me. My youngest had a lot less of me when she was a baby. She got fed, changed, given a kiss and then put down. I was BUSY and stressed in her first year. As a baby she was happy to sit and watch the world go by (but honestly she didn't have a choice). She has been forced to investigate the world and play much more independently and now that's how she prefers to be. She also doesn't crave physical attention and touch from me. It's very different from my son. I know we love each other but I do worry that she doesn't feel enough love from me. (This is making me really sad to write). I think part of it is her natural personality but it's also definitely because she was forced to be more independent.
Anyway rambling now.....
Don't change anything you are doing. You can NOT love a baby too much. If it feels right then do that. Your baby is 'whiny' because he is learning how to communicate his needs to you. Life will throw you plenty of reasons that you can't give him exactly what he wants when he wants it but 4 months is not the time for that! In fact a well attached baby who knows its mother always attends to its needs will be much more settled in the world. He soon won't cry for you as much because he feels secure in the knowledge that you are always close and that a cuddle is only a few minutes away.
He cries when mil holds him because he likes you better! You're the light of his life. Mil will just have to deal with it! Also I found that my babies always preferred people that they saw often (at least once a week) and people that were happy to take the baby's lead. People who got right in their faces and tried to force smiles, cuddles and wanted baby to put on a show are never the favorite. Those who listen to babys cues and respect their boundaries defiantly became my babies favorite people.
Hope some of that answers your question..... Xxx
01-08-2016 18:40 #14
01-08-2016 18:51 #15-
- Join Date
- Apr 2012
2 kids here. My guess is:
There are a lot of things that are within parental control (eg many aspects of settling and sleeping), however sometimes it doesn't matter what you do there are underlying conditions affecting bubs behaviors.
The Following User Says Thank You to VicPark For This Useful Post:
01-08-2016 18:53 #16
Ummmm, being clingy and not wanting anyone other than their primary caregivers (and even just sometimes mum, and only mum) is typical leap 4 behaviour.
It's just bub developing. Tell MIL it's normal for kids not to like her!!!!
01-08-2016 19:26 #17
I only have one kid but my DS was EXACTLY the same. He never happily went to anyone except me or DP. By 18 months he happily went to MIL. By 2, my FIL and SIL. Only now at 2.9 he's started to be happy to spend time with my mum and dad.
He had seen them a lot less as a baby and it showed!
Luckily no one pushed the issue and it's really nice knowing he is now choosing to interact with them of his own accord.
Quite a lot of studies have shown that boys brains develop slower than girls which is why baby boys are generally more affectionate, less independent and have more sleep issues than baby girls.
(Of course that's *generally*, not every case!)
The Following User Says Thank You to rainbow road For This Useful Post:
01-08-2016 19:55 #18Senior Member
- Join Date
- May 2014
My oldest - had my undivided attention for 21 months...has hated affection since school age, happiest when working independently. My other kids enjoy company more.
My youngest had to share me a lot and there was a lot of meeting needs without nurturing. Most cuddliest, affectionate kid that ever existed and actually asks me if we can just sit and cuddle all day.
The Following User Says Thank You to Full House For This Useful Post:
01-08-2016 20:06 #19
I have two. Both have been parented pretty similar. Breastfed to sleep, cosleep, baby wear, shocking sleepers though DS was slightly better at napping.
Both pretty easy going babies. Especially DS. He was a super chilled baby and now he's a sweet mostly chilled toddler, except if he's sick and then he is unmanageable.
Neither had no problem being held by other people. Both very sociable babies. Greatest difficulty for someone else would be getting them to sleep, especially DD.
Eta - they probably didn't get whiny until that 10/11 month when they started to chuck mini tantrums. But they have always been pretty happy kids unless you cross them lol
Oh and I meant to add, I think its just a personality thing.
Last edited by smallpotatoes; 01-08-2016 at 20:16.
01-08-2016 20:27 #20
Please don't listen to people who tell you you're holding your child too much. Babies need to feel safe and loved, and they go through phases of wanting to be held more and having separation anxiety. They will go through these phases regardless of your parenting.
You're doing a great job, nothing is your "fault". You can't spoil a baby. Just do whatever you feel your baby needs.
Little Rugby NSWCatch, weave, chase, run, but most of all have FUN! Little Rugby runs a NSW network of fun, safe and non-contact footy ...
FORUMS - chatting now ...
Finances as a coupleFamily Finances
Roller blinds adviceGeneral Chat
Come chat, Ladies who are 40+ TTC or ExpectingConception & Fertility General Chat
I am... #20General Chat
April/May TTC group chatConception & Fertility General Chat
IVF Babies due August/Sept/Oct' 16 #4pregnancy and babies through IVF
Pokemon go. Chat #2General Chat
Vegetarian recipes for those with low ironRecipes & Lunchbox Ideas
IVF/FET April & May chatConception & Fertility General Chat