Currently all commerical surrogacy in Australia is illegal, only altruistic surrogacy is permitted. The intended parents are allowed to pay expenses - but that is it.
As far as overseas commercial surrogacy - the laws for each state are different. some states allow it and others do not.
Whatever - it is clear the current mumbo-jumbo mix is not really appropriate.
So - what do YOU think we should do? Should we allow commercial surrogacy?
Should intended parents be allowed to pay the person who is giving them the ultimate gift?
Or does this only encourage the activity of people in extreme hardship 'selling' their womb ... possibly under duress from family or others.
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 21
06-08-2014 19:52 #1
Should Commercial Surrogacy be legal? Should overseas surrogacy be illegal? WDYT
06-08-2014 19:52 #2
06-08-2014 19:56 #3
Yes, I think commercial surrogacy in Australia should be allowed.
I think the power balance is much more equal for someone in Australia who may not have much money and is turning to surrogacy to make some money vs someone in poverty in a developing country. There is just way too much risk of exploitation in developing countries.
I would prefer to see commercial surrogacy in overseas countries illegal for Australians, and commercial surrogacy legal in Australia.
Last edited by NoteToSelf; 06-08-2014 at 20:13.
06-08-2014 20:06 #4
Last edited by headoverfeet; 06-08-2014 at 20:10.
06-08-2014 20:10 #5
I think it's hard & unless you've found yourself in this position of needing a surrogate it is hard to answer.
Infertility is such a hard road as it is without making it more difficult for couples to get their take home baby.
I don't think couples should have to pay more than medical expenses. I have had friends that have looked into surrogacy & with legal fee's etc it is insanely expensive. And not to mention emotionally draining.
I do think however that the person being the surrogate needs to be adequately looked after & not taken advantage of.
I know there are a lot of lovely ladies on here that need the option of surrogacy & I'd hate to think this recent event in the media has made it even more harder & mentally tougher than what it already was.
06-08-2014 20:13 #6
I agree Rocky we need medicare funding for surrogacy! I disagree that they shouldnt have to pay more than medical costs, all costs associated with the pregnancy need to be covered (as they are) loss of wages, travel costs, maternity clothing...pretty much anything you would pay for if you were expecting yourself.
Last edited by headoverfeet; 06-08-2014 at 20:15.
06-08-2014 20:18 #7
I think it is a nice idea to think of altruistic surrogacy as being able to meet the needs of all couples who need it. But unfortunately I just don't think it is realistic, I personally would not be an altruistic surrogate (except for a family member or close friend), but I would consider it if say I could pay for a chunk of my kids education or something.
06-08-2014 20:18 #8
It is hard.
Its something I might have considered if DH was willing (I cannot have another baby) ...
But I would desperately have liked the opportunity to do something nice (in monetary terms) for the person who would be making such an enormous difference to my life.
By the same token - some people being able to do that might then result in all surrogates expecting that kind of payment, and make it unreachable for people who are not able to offer that
06-08-2014 20:22 #9
06-08-2014 20:27 #10
Oh - thats pretty crap HOF.
I thought they were allowed to buy you small token gifts (like a hamper of food or a piece of jewellery to remember ...
Baby MonitorsLooking to buy a baby monitor? :: Read viewer reviews of baby monitors BEFORE you buy :: Buy at a local or online Baby ...
LATESTToilet training: when is the best time to start?Why it is OK for your child to be differentWhat is a blessing way? How is it different to a baby shower?
POPULARWhen can I start giving chores to my children?New baby nursery checklist – a guide to newborn essentialsWhat to pack for labour and hospital – a checklist
FORUMS - chatting now ...
Dr Antony Lighten - Appreciation threadpregnancy and babies through IVF
Funniest thing your kid has said to youGeneral Chat
Rude 10 year old. Ideas?General Chat
Egg/donor code discussion - South AfricaEgg Donation
Happiness thread.General Chat
Awesome Mums of Autistic kids-how many of us are there (#3)????????Parents of Children with Special Needs
Support out there? ED issues, ttcMale Infertility Issues