I mean, actually measuring these constructs (ie frequency of praise and bullying behaviour by children)?
+ Reply to Thread
Results 31 to 35 of 35
31-05-2012 18:45 #31
31-05-2012 18:57 #32-
- Join Date
- Nov 2011
- Western Sydney
Bullying often stems from being bullied, it's a vicious circle!
Does everyone remember Casey Heynis? The kid that was bullied in a Western Sydney high school and power-slammed his bully? Weeellllll I was the stupid idiot that sent his video viral, gave him endless support, and became a huge anti-bully advocate! One year later and Casey is banned from my house because he bullies my son.
So Casey was given love and support by people of all walks of life, and in turn he became the very person he despised - a bully!
31-05-2012 20:36 #33
This particular researcher is talking about existing research indicating that a focus on self esteem has produced more young people low on empathy and high on narcissism. I don't believe she is referring to one particular study where they found praise was causing children to bully but rather she is discussing the results of many studies over the last 30 years showing a pattern and concluding that based on these studies excessive praise "could" be a risk factor.
In saying that i am sure there would be studies looking at just that, however i do not have the time tonight to have a look through.
I have already given a number of studies which suggest that an inflated self-esteem increases the odds of aggressive behavior/bullying such as (Baumeister, 2001; Bushman & Baumeister, 1998). There is quite a bit of empirical evidence in support of this - so after looking through the 30 years of research, it would seem a theme has arisen. If I wasn't studying for my exams i would go through some studies and pick put some tidbits, but time does not allow tonight i am afraid.
I thought this interview between the researcher in question and George Negus provided some good insights into bullying in general though;
Last edited by Ulysses; 31-05-2012 at 21:03.
31-05-2012 21:06 #34
I think there's a difference between narcissism and high self esteem. My personal opinion is that praise alone doesn't create narcissism if it's taught with humility. It usually comes with parents that teach the 'survival of the fittest' competitive mentality, where they say things like "you beat billy bc he sucks at running and you're a much better runner", rather than "wow, you tried so hard and you did so well!".
Personally I think bullying stems from low self esteem. The over inflated sense of self esteem and entitlement is just a facade. I liken it to comedians that often report suffering depression and bullying as kids and say a sense of homour was a way of covering up how unhappy they were. They were the joker therefore that was their identity. A bully bullies to pump up his own lack of self esteem and get external validation from others. But that's JMHO.
01-06-2012 06:07 #35
There is a difference between narcissism and self esteem, I think the article is making a link between the focus on self esteem and narcissism/low empathy - not that they are the same thing. This theory has been around for some time now. The main point is that if we try too hard to raise our kids self esteem by praising inappropriately then there is the risk of creating narcissistic tendencies such as;
- Believing that you're better than others
- Fantasizing about power, success and attractiveness
- Exaggerating your achievements or talents
- Expecting constant praise and admiration
- Believing that you're special and acting accordingly
- Failing to recognize other people's emotions and feelings
- Expecting others to go along with your ideas and plans
- Taking advantage of others
- Expressing disdain for those you feel are inferior
- Being jealous of others
- Believing that others are jealous of you
- Trouble keeping healthy relationships
- Setting unrealistic goals
- Being easily hurt and rejected
- Having a fragile self-esteem
- Appearing as tough-minded or unemotional
As opposed to thinking of it as too much praise, I think the point of the article is surrounding too much praise done inappropriately in an attempt to build a child's self esteem, where it is better to have a balanced approach, criticism and mistakes can be a good learning tool. If everything they do is wonderful then they certainly could end up with an inflated sense of self and it wouldnt be too far a stretch to see how that could affect ones tendency towards narcissism or low empathy.
Here is a child psychologist talking a bit about over praising, maybe they will explain it a bit better than I. Also a video on praise effort vs result.
I also think this video outlines the difference between praise and positive acknowledgement very well. It can be confusing about how much and when is best for your kids development.
There are also a couple of different styles of bullying, but the leading research on bullying has shown that a common type of bully (school jock.popular kid type) is actually high on self esteem. There are a number of studies that have been done on this topic and it is what they are teaching in Psychology courses at university. One of the worlds leading researchers on Bullying has provided some information that describes the profile of bully, and it is often the bully victim that suffers from low self esteem sadly, and even worse a large number of kids who are bullied are those with special needs or other issues.
I do think there are also types of bullies that are low in self esteem but I don't they are influenced by over praising or inappropriate praising, it is probably quite the opposite with them.
Every kid is different and every parent has their own style, but i can certainly see the value in praising when appropriate versus praising everything a child does in order to build self esteem. Realistic and task/time appropriate praising and encouragement should be adequate. I should add I am confident most parents instinctually know this anyway, sometimes there is so much conflicting advice, but in the end balance wins out if you ask me.
Last edited by Ulysses; 01-06-2012 at 08:58.
By WorkingClassMum in forum Social IssuesReplies: 11Last Post: 20-03-2012, 21:17
Swim AustraliaSwim Australia are the leading learn-to-swim experts, and national swim school authority. With over 600 Registered Swim ...
LATESTSurrogacy and why many parents break the lawHow to get your kids to bring home empty lunch boxesIs the secret to saving for your child’s education in your home loan?
POPULARWhen can I start giving chores to my children?New baby nursery checklist – a guide to newborn essentialsWhat to pack for labour and hospital – a checklist
FORUMS - chatting now ...
Is a week to early for signs??Conception & Fertility General Chat
Egg Donation in Greece #5Egg Donation
What are our chances??pregnancy and babies through IVF
Egg Donation in South Africa #14Egg Donation
Local Infant Adoption in VictoriaAdoption / Surrogacy
Asking for a friend - names ending in 'ee'Choosing Baby Names
Power back pain! Help!!General Chat
Help with 7 week scan interpretationFirst Trimester Chat
I am... #20General Chat