Hi, I really need some advice. My son has just turned 2 and is a wonderful, but VERY demanding boy. I really want him to lose the dummy. He has always used a dummy for sleeping and sometimes when he got whingy during the day. I also let him have it in the car as I have a long drive to work on a busy highway with him, and it is just too distracting and dangerous if he is throwing a tantrum all the way. Lately he has gotten so much more attached to it and is obsessed with it. He goes absolutely nuts if he doesn't have it and won't calm down. I am terribly sick with morning sickness which is making me a bit depressed so I've just given in and let him have it because I can't handle the all day long tantrum if I don't.
I've tried cutting the end off in bits or poking holes in it. He just sucks it anyway, and if I cut it too short, it's tantrums again.
He is bilingual, so his language skills are spread over two languages. He doesn't know enough in one language to be able to reason with. He wouldn't understand the concept or explanation of 'losing it', 'fairies coming to take it', or 'giving it to babies who need it' etc.
I do kind of feel sorry for him even when he's throwing tantrums about it because he is just so incredibly upset.
Does anyone have ANY advice - if I just make him quit it cold turkey, how long can I expect the tantrums to last? I am also worried about the lack of sleep if I did this as I am so sick, have to work, and sleeplessness is the LAST thing I need.
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 17
17-03-2012 21:28 #1Senior Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2011
PLEASE help me get 2 yr old off the dummy!!!!! PLEASE!!!!
17-03-2012 22:32 #2
DD1 loved her dummy. at 2 i restricted it to bedtime and in the car and had a little drawstring bag in the cot and car for her to put the dummy in when she got out. took only a few days before she got the hang of this.
at 2.5 she wanted to go to ballet class so i told her the dummies had to go and she happily gathered them up and tossed the lot and never spoke of them again.
i was glad i had waited till she was ready to give them away as we never had to deal with drama about them
The Following User Says Thank You to RmumR For This Useful Post:
17-03-2012 22:34 #3
Do you HAVE to make him give up his dummy? He is only 2, I would just let him have it until you are better able to deal with removing it, or he is old enough to understand it. Most people I know get rid of it at about 3, using the fairies, easter bunny, santa type stories. My nephew at 3 had to have 3 at night, one for his mouth and one for each hand! I would set up some rules, like only in the car, in bed and when resting on the lounge or something, and be firm with it. Remember 2 is the age for tanties anyway, so if it wasn't dummies it could well be something else! If he was a thumb-sucker he would be sucking it for a long time yet!
Having said that, it seems that (at age 3 anyway) to take about 3-4 nights/days to go "cold turkey" and pretty sleep disturbed nights sometimes.
Path of least resistance on this I reckon! IMO
17-03-2012 22:38 #4Senior Member
- Join Date
- Sep 2008
My DD's gave them up on their own at 1 but I reintroduced them at 2 because of the separation anxiety and tantrums that followed. They just needed a comfort, something I couldn't offer to both of them 24/7.
They will be 3 next month and they have been without dummies for a month now.
I cut the teat off and showed them they were broken and they through them in the bin themselves.
I'd wait until he was ready or had a little more understanding.
17-03-2012 23:01 #5
Taking everything you have just said into consideration, I'd let him have it. He's two, an age when it's difficult to negotiate anyway and you sound like you are juggling enough for now
He won't have it/need it forever and for now it sounds like it's not worth the struggle. Hope you feel better soon
18-03-2012 00:25 #6Senior Member
- Join Date
- Oct 2010
Id cut it down to just nap and sleep. See how he goes then donw the track give it to the fairies or something. Hes clearly dependant on it but DONT WORRY. it wont be forever. My dentist once told me, you dont need to worry about these things until they turn 5.
We waited til DD was 3 and got her off it then. She understaood more and SHE actually left it out for the fairies!!!
18-03-2012 00:31 #7
My friend made a big deal of Easter last year. for her two year old and made her daughter give her dummy to the Easter bunny. It worked
18-03-2012 00:38 #8
Start small. If he is chucking a tanty tell him he must stop or dummy goes in the bin. Give it to him when he calms down. This way he will see that the tantrums have no power. If he drops it and forgets about it for awhile put it out of sight and see if that works for awhile. You can gradually increase this till he only has it for sleep/rest/car or under especially stressful situations. If you want it off him soon, riding the tantrums is a must. Even at two they know how to tug at the heart strings. If language is a problem try some simple hand signs or over exaggerated body language to support your statements as children at that age respond quicker to visual cues than verbal ones.
18-03-2012 01:33 #9Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2011
I personally havent had to go through this... yet
But I do have a friend who, went through this after trying many different methos, she bought packets of the same dummy her bub but in different sizes, and decreased the dummy size over a few weeks to new born size, after a week or so with the new born size she was completely off the dummy - which im assuming is because it would be harder for them to suck on and maybe not so comforting?
18-03-2012 03:39 #10
Oh lordy, the hardship of morning sickness! I spent the better part of 4 months flat on my back because every time I moved I felt like I was going to lose my intestines
As for the dummy, I have always restricted dummy use to bedtime only. Even now my youngest has a dummy for sleep time and if she feels she wants it during non-sleep times, then she has to be on her bed with it. Do you think you feel up to trying a similar compromise? It might take a couple of days to get it in place, but it would be worth it.
Also, having the dummy in the car. Are you able to put on a CD of nursery rhymes he likes and distract him that way? While you are implementing the "dummy only in bed" rule, you could play a CD when you first get into the car and hold off on giving him the dummy until he really needs it and try to stretch out this no-dummy time every day.
Good luck whatever you choose to do. I hope the morning sickness eases soon and you have a lovely pregnancy
By GLM in forum General Parenting Tips, Advice & ChatReplies: 27Last Post: 28-12-2012, 12:17
By pilbarablossom in forum General Parenting Tips, Advice & ChatReplies: 11Last Post: 21-11-2012, 07:28
By cakester69 in forum General Sleeping & Settling ChatReplies: 21Last Post: 18-02-2012, 23:09
Transition into Parenthood / Calmbirth SydneyJulie's Transition into Parenthood and Calmbirth courses for pregnant couples will get you ready, prepared and ...
LATESTHow to get your kids to bring home empty lunch boxesIs the secret to saving for your child’s education in your home loan?Games to play with your baby – newborn to 12 months
POPULARWhen can I start giving chores to my children?New baby nursery checklist – a guide to newborn essentialsWhat to pack for labour and hospital – a checklist
FORUMS - chatting now ...
Tell them they're dreaming! Buy-Swap-SellGeneral Chat
What age can teenagers consent to flu needles?Immunisation & Vaccines
Come chat, Ladies who are 40+ TTC or ExpectingConception & Fertility General Chat
April/May TTC group chatConception & Fertility General Chat
unplanned pregnancyConception & Fertility General Chat
What did you compromise on when buying or building a house?House & Gardens