Is it so you can call me white and ignorant and prejudiced?
If you must know, I live in a low socio economic area and work in a low skilled/paid job, so it's a big mix, but the majority of my friends are white. Not all, but most.
Does that mean I am not entitled to debate whether it is working?
You have completely misunderstood me.
I've told you my reasons for why I think i am beginning to think it won't work- people are unable to live harmoniously together, the rise in radicalism and terrorism, that a large chunk of the population have negative views and opinions of the other, the situation in Europe, the rise of Pauline Hanson and Brexit. Humans as a whole are crappy.
I'm getting frustrated and you have still not convinced me it can work long term, particularly in Europe.
I'm out. This is why I'm so reluctant to discuss it, it's so easy to manipulate ones words and because I'm white I'm clearly prejudiced and ignorant and scared of Muslims. (Which I'm not, and was not the point I was making).
Last edited by Little Miss Sunshine; 16-07-2016 at 10:14.
They are scared because their way of life is being threatened, or I should say they assume their way of life is going to change ,
it's ignorance , anything that's not the same as what we do , we believe is inferior , we take on opinions of those we hang out with, we judge people based on their religion, race , or what they wear , we blame other people for our problems ( minority groups taking jobs, Asians pushing up house prices etc ) that all breeds racism and yes the media fuels the fire
I've been selling people's homes in and around the Hurstville , Lakemba and St George areas for 25 years, I've listed and sold to just about every ethnic and religious group there is , I've had, and still do have your older "Australian" owners tell me not to sell their home to Muslims, or Asians ( or which ever group they don't like) as it will ruin the neighbourhood- it's purely fear of the Unknown - I've also thankfully seen all these minority groups fit in beautifully with these older Aussies once they actually give them the time to get to know them
Yes it's fear of the unknown and fear of change or perceived change.
I think multiculturalism can and does work among those who are open to it but there will always be those who aren't. So i couldn't say that everyone, everywhere will get along one day. But i think that multicultural communities can definitely thrive.
Little Miss Sunshine (16-07-2016)
I believe in the human race and in the love between all the people of different countries and religions.
People of scared of the unknown. Once you're able to put faces against what scares you, you realise that people from other countries and religions are just the same as you. Same love for their families, same daily worries, same hope for the future.
I don't believe the world is scariest today but I believe our western world had been protected from war/terrorism deaths for a long time. Other countries weren't so lucky.
Coming from France, I can say that multicuralism works over there in many areas but we have also created terrible pockets of drugs and poverty by parking migrants in suburbs only made of terrible commission flats.
I personally found Australia with louder racist views than France. Maybe it's because it seems ok to voice racists comments here?! No idea.
Overall I see many communities living in harmony alongside each other here in Melbourne.
As for our way of life being sustainable, I do believe we make too many children and we buy too much stuff.
A survey in France was showing that the people who had the most negative opinions towards other communities where the one living in the areas with no other communities than their own...
The one that lived in a mix of communities had positive sentiment.
Yes it's easily explained that the first group is scared because all they "know" about these communities are through the news.
The second group though know that these communities are just the same than themselves.
Struggling to find a work, worried about money and paying the bills, rushing home to look after the family... Just the same. Only different clothes/skin colour/religion etc
@LittleMissSunshine I get where you're coming from. It is frustrating to see legitimate questions dismissed as implying you obviously just don't understand and are clearly racist.
I am mixed race. I am 'multicultural'. I have lived in many multicultural communities. I am not racist. My questioning multiculturalism is not questioning whether 'other people' can live in 'my country'. It doesn't mean I don't understand it, or can't see the benefits of a functioning multicultural community.
It is questioning whether *all* people of different belief systems, language backgrounds, and yes, in some instances, value systems, can find a way to inhabit the same space peacefully. I think many Australian indigenous people would say no. Recent events would suggest no.
I think manipulating this into just a comment against Islam is disingenuous. My suggesting multiculturalism isn't necessarily working isn't the same as saying 'people should just go back where they come from'. It's just acknowledging that there are examples all over the world where it doesn't seem to be working. These countries aren't all western, and it isn't a recent issue.
It hurts me to admit. But I think it's an important conversation.
Last edited by Yoghurt; 24-07-2016 at 18:42.
@Yoghurt I agree with you about the media. I was so cranky when I read the driver 'was heard to have cried Allahu Akbar (God is Great) just before he died'. Because I'm sure over the crying, screaming, and noise of gunfire that everyone could totally hear that 😡
Pregnant for the first-time?
Not sure where to start? We can help!
Our Insider Programs for pregnancy first-timers will lead you step-by-step through the 14 Pregnancy Must Dos!