@[Mod] Nomsie My DH did he exact same thing and I still have moments where I feel a little sad that I didn't get that proper proposal and we have just celebrated our 4th wedding anniversary. You'd think I'd be over it by now!!
As for the op, If in time you still don't love it (as in years down the track) maybe you could go down the this ring isn't my style anymore (or something along those lines) and get a different one. Or just 'accidentally' lose it, hehe!