No, science belongs in school!
No, science belongs in school!
Radio National - Talk back (your chance to call in if you want to) on NOW 9:00am [I'm in NSW]
Listen to the volunteers and parents
EDIT to add online catch of broadcast
Last edited by FiveInTheBed; 06-02-2015 at 18:56.
I did not listen to the audio but I read the text.
No, I don't think religion has any place in public school, I won't be consenting for my kids to attend scripture or to have any contact with chaplains.
Yes, the Police Check is good in theory but as someone who resides in SA, I didn't get one and had access to children as a volunteer. There are plenty of gaps in the system.
I think the title of this thread is flawed. Should be more along the lines of "Should religion be taught as a subject in school?"
To which I would answer yes.
I feel it is important to be knowledgeable about this apart from the fact that studying comparative religions is very interesting. To keep my children in the dark about what is a very fundamental part of life would be a disservice to them.
I learned about many religions in primary school including how to recognise a cult, how to protect oneself from nutters and how to discern which is right and not right for you. Really interesting stuff. We also visited various sites such as churches of various denominations, attended a Hindu celebration, talked with people of varying faiths etc. Again, all important information which I have found has stood me in good stead in life.
In terms of unqualified chaplains though, no way will my kids get access to them. I believe the government's chaplaincy programme is dangerous and should be immediately eradicated.
I try to keep scrolling when a thread like this is started.
Ill keep it short and simple, no. If i wanted my child to do religious education id send them to a private school. My son won't be participating in RE.
I have not read replys because I'm sure someone would have said this but...
I think re is the parents job.
If your wanting your child to learn ANY or all religious beliefs it should be done at home and at church. Not in school where there are so many differing religions to cover and they only teach one.
No, religion has no place in public schools. School is a place where children go to learn factual things, and they see 'teachers' (incl volunteers) as people who convey factual information to them. Especially young children beleive what the teacher tells them as fact. A study published in the Cognitive Science journal has found that young children who are indoctrinated into a relgion have difficulty in being able to distingiugh fact from fiction - eg. if shown a talking animal, they will believe that it is real. (Article from Huff Post with link to journal study here http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/5607009)
I think an ethics class is a fantastic idea! Then when children are old enough to understand that people hold different beliefs, but that doesn't make those beliefs 'fact', perhaps introduce a program where SRE instructors from all different religions come in for a few sessions to discuss the basics of their beliefs & the associated customs. This would encourage children to have an open mind, and to be understanding and respectful of different religions & beliefs, at a time when they can distingiugh a belief from a fact.
Last edited by littlelove; 07-02-2015 at 07:51.
I think religious studies should be an elective in high school, but I don't think it has a place beyond that.
If you want your child/ren to learn about your beliefs, or others too, that should be in your own time or at a specific school.
Pregnant for the first-time?
Not sure where to start? We can help!
Our Insider Programs for pregnancy first-timers will lead you step-by-step through the 14 Pregnancy Must Dos!