I forgot to mention the snuggle blanket (aka benny the night night bunny 😛) worked really well. It took her few days to show any interest in him but she holds onto it all night now. I'm so grateful for the suggestion and would definitely recommend it to anyone when they stop swaddling!
I can't quite bring myself believe it's going to stay like this. I'd hate for it to turn out the last two nights were a fluke!