Kay - so glad to hear you have DH on board. I'd agree with the other ladies. We started out with what we thought was a good list of criteria. I too first thought intelligence was an important one but eventually our criteria dwindled down to just the basics : health/medical history, age, proven donor. I'd say if you like what you see - go for it! While the profiles can give us a general idea I don't think they can give a deep insight into the 'whole being' of our donor. We do have to somewhat rely on 'gut feeling'.
Faith : you can take the progynova (same thing) with or without food it doesn't matter. You just need to take it at roughly the same time everyday (a bit like the pill).