It is not easier on the dole. It's horrible on the dole.
I know when I was growing up I was partially raised by my grandparents due to parental illness and work commitments and I find nothing shameful in that and I loved them dearly and had a better relationship with them than my own mother. This wouldn't always be the case, but just what happened in mine. I doubt that my mother would be offended if someone implied that my grandparents helped to raise her children because that is what happened.
As parents we make decisions about who has an influence and care over our children during the time they are raised from infancy, however if our children are in the care of others for a large part of their waking hours those people could be considered to be helping to raise that child. I think it comes down to what a person thinks it is to raise a child and that's okay. I have no problem saying that my children's child care workers and teachers are helping me to raise my children as they all spend such a large portion of time with them, teaching them and have a certain level of influence in their lives.
Edit: Took me so long to respond in between working on my assignment that others already replied in the same manner...oh well...back to work.
Last edited by Little Ted; 16-05-2014 at 22:40.
Look, I'm all for the country wanting it citizens to reach their potential and contribute where they can. But you seem to have a limited understanding how crap the pay is. What does just over $500 a fortnight get you these days? We live in the country when rent is dirt cheap in comparison to the capital cities and we pay 500 a fortnight. In the city that would be lucky to get you a bedsitter, let alone pay for power, food, petrol and phone to look for work.
If this free money is so good, and being on the dole just involves sitting on your rear end, why don't you trade places with one of these people for a week?
In this case I would say my Aunty is raising her grandkid while her precious daughter is putting another feather in precious high flying career cap.
However despite some people not doing the right thing some of the time, there are people who are doing the right thing all of the time. Punishing people because of the actions of a few makes no sense.
Often there are just no jobs there to be had, or they require training that people can't afford etc.
We cannot leave people without a safety net and no way of eating and living, because someone might do the wrong thing.
The rhetoric seems to be they need to incentivise people. They needed to push sole parents on to Newstart to incentivise them to work, - when the majority are already working.
They need to stop giving people disability pensions to incentivise them to work, despite the fact that many do work when they can, and many people with clear acute disabilities cannot get a disability pension.
THey need to incentivise young people to work, even though most will give almost anything a go, and there just aren't enough jobs, and making them desperate will put them in terrible situations where they will be taken advantage of etc
They need to incentivise older adults to work, despite many people discriminating against them due to age, and again most people wanting to work.
They have eroded workers rights over and where companies used to have lots of permenant employees - places like target and K mart have mostly casual and part timers, keeping people on benifits for longer as their hours are cut in slow times and they don't get holidays/sick pay/ holidays- this leaves them vulnerable.
Therre are lots of issues that stop people from getting employment.
I think assuming people need a push to do so is ridiculous. I've known some very poor people, I do know that none of them wanted to be poor, and would take the opportunity when given to further themselves, and be able to pay the rent and buy food.
Secondly, I've been a poor uni student who lived on less than that, at the time the dole actually paid more than youth allowance ( not sure if that's the same now). I couldn't be bothered with cl as I was casual it was too hard to predict what my income would be and the few months I did claim i ended up owing. so I ended up begging work to put me pt ( still less than the dole payment) How did I survive? I lived with 4 others in a run down shack, I tried to scheduled classes on the same day to avoid extra transport costs. I used text books from the library and brought 2nd hand. I cooked from scratch simple cheap ( but healthy meals). I went to the free clinic at uni, got my hair cut by student hair dressers, bought 2nd hand or Kmart etc. It was a few YEARS of pain but I am ambitious and knew I did not want to follow in my families footsteps.
I've walked the walk so I have a right to talk the talk. I grew up in an extremely poor single parent house hold solely reliant on handouts, I knew I did not want that to continue. It also allowed me an incite into the minds of my fellow classmates as I was in a low socio economic area, I know how they think, and still keep in contact with many.
I know hard work = success. I got a job as soon as I was old enough earning $4 an hour. I spent most of my life doing it tough and it's only in the past few years I've benefited from my hard work.
I'm not talking out of my **** here I'm talking from genuine life experience.
I don't know why you continue to try and discredit me. Maybe jealously that I've broken the cycle?
I'm not discrediting you, I'm simply asking you to look outside the box here. You see, IMO, everything so one dimensionally.
I know I lack empathy, but that's based from my own personal experience. I'm not a pollie who has sat in my ivory tower my entire life. If I can do it why can't others? Start from the ground up. Who really wants that life anyway? It doesn't have to be that way.
Based on the background you described you've obviously relied on yourself too.
We obviously are not going to sway each other's opinions on this matter.
For the record I don't hold grudges and get involved in clicks. We don't agree here but maybe we might on different topics. I certainly do not let a difference of opinion sway me.
Pregnant for the first-time?
Not sure where to start? We can help!
Our Insider Programs for pregnancy first-timers will lead you step-by-step through the 14 Pregnancy Must Dos!