Haha no problems!
Things I have learnt from this thread
- some people had great experiences at public hospitals
- some people had great experiences at private hospitals
- some people had bad experiences at public hospitals
- some people had bad experiences at private hospitals
- some people want a midwife managed pregnancy
- some people want a medically managed pregnancy
- some people hated their OB
- some people loved their OB
- some people hated their midwife
- some people loved their midwife
It's pointless sitting here and everyone saying 'i had a wonderful birth at a private hospital, therefore everyone should go private' or 'I had a wonderful waterbirth at a public hospital therefore everyone should go public'.
That doesn't help, because there is no blanket 'wonderful birth experience', everyone has a different idea.
Putting all of Australia into one statistic is pointless as it balances out the extremes on either end of the spectrum. It's silly to say private hospitals in NSW have a 75% Caesar rate (making that up), therefore you shouldn't go private if you don't want a caesar when the private hospital in your town actually only has a 10% Caesar rate.
So my suggestion is - figure out what you want and seek the care provider in your areas that is going to give it to you. General public vs private debates are pointless because as this thread as shown there is a wide spectrum of experiences that have been had in private and public hospitals across Australia. And what may be your ideal experience may be someone else's worst nightmare.
Last edited by wannawannabe; 10-09-2012 at 21:06.
And in case you haven't noticed this has turned into a public vs private debate.
You also need to look at the reasons for increased caesarean rates. There are more high risk women having babies then there was ever before, there are more women choosing interventions (such as epidurals) that put them at a high risk of a caesarean section, there are women electing to chose them, there are more caesareans being performed for breech and multiple births. Not saying its a bad thing, but there a multitude of reasons as to why caesarean section rates may have increased and its impossible to pinpoint them because there could never be a blind trial carried out.
I don't believe any ob's in this day age give everyone patient they see an episiotomy, I was asked by my ob in a public hospital, but even he said he was leaning towards not doing one.
In my case I can say that not all ob's want to go the intervention way without cause.
Sorry cant resist.
GRRRRRR THIS STUDY IS ANNOYING ME.
It's completely flawed and I'm miffed it's getting any kind of air time at all because the bit they forgot to include makes the numbers entirely irrelevant.
The women surveyed were not asked whether their interventions were requested or not.
Yet these figures are being tossed around as though they speak for unwanted intervention. They DO NOT. Whether the women planned elective c-sections or not is not taken into account, whether a woman was exhausted and asked for ventouse assistance is not taken into account. We all know women that request epidurals, they're rarely "forced" onto people. It doesn't take this into account at all, only that interventions happened.
Well interventions aren't always inflicted upon women who don't want them. This study is making noise like they are.
It's COMPLETELY irrelevant as any kind of statement without this information. Interventions don't happen in a vacuum. There are plenty of times interventions are requested, and for them to not take this into account is ridiculous.
If they asked whether the interventions were wanted or not, THEN they might have some interesting stats with which to start a conversation -- but they don't want to start a conversation, they just want to make private hospitals look like they're salivating while waiting to gut us all like fish. They just want to say "Intervention baaaaad, natural, gooooood!" like it was that simple.
Absolute rubbish and shouldn't be getting the kind of traction it is.
Pregnant for the first-time?
Not sure where to start? We can help!
Our Insider Programs for pregnancy first-timers will lead you step-by-step through the 14 Pregnancy Must Dos!