My intact husband is clean. My two boy children are clean. They are not feral, nor do they smell.
I don't know how you think you know more about circumcision than every medical authority in every developed/western nation (none of which recommend routine circumcision).
I suggest you are circ'ing for cultural/family reasons and are trying to distort medical opinion to back your stance.?
How anyone can take a knife to their child for a 7% statistic well I guess we just have different thresholds.
You are circ'ing for religious and cultural reasons so own it. Don't throw ridiculous hygiene reasons into the debate.
- perhaps your son will be incapable of washing his willy but mine won't.
Last edited by VicPark; 29-08-2012 at 19:57.
I assume from this they would then only support circ for established health reasons, which anti-ric supporters would support. We just don't support RIC where there is no established health reason or for any cultural or religious reasons (well, I don't, I can't speak for all).
I don't know about anyone else, but I get all of my medical info from "Can of worms".....doesn't everybody?
Yes beebs.. I thought that was the entire point of that show? So that people became more educated on issues such as circumcisition without having to talk to medical professionals.
I just couldn't do it... As a mum I feel for those who have to for religious reasons... I would be a mess.
Also does anyone think it's painful? I mean do they really think a baby doesn't feel that? I'm just happy I don't have to deal with this.
The only thing we can all agree on here is that anti-circumcisors believe wholeheartedly in bodily autonomy and pro-circumcisors don't.
Even if I did want to circumcise my son I wouldn't use the AAP's findings to back up my decision as I don't think it would add any strength to my case in any way - they haven't presented any reason to justify circumcising my son!
I just believe heart and soul that my baby boy was born perfect, the way nature intended it and I have no right to inflict any unnecessary pain on him and make surgical adjustments to his body.
There are no very strong reasons why it should be done these days and no-one can really agree there was ever a strong reason that made it necessary in ancient times when the practice began.
Both my brothers - aged 47 and 35 are circumcised. When I had a son 4 years ago I asked both of them separately what their thoughts were and they both felt its not a parents choice to make and shouldnt be done. They are very different people from different generations and yet had very similar feelings.
America is not a good example to follow. A friend of mine had prem twins on holiday in new York at 24 weeks. Tragically one passed away. When the surviving twins was just 2 weeks and struggling every day to survive, unbelievably the hospital asked if my friend would like him circumcised.
You can tell from the depictions in American popular culture (sex and the city etc) that uncircumcised penises are considered funny looking etc.
The cultural bias towards circumcision in America is immense.
Pregnant for the first-time?
Not sure where to start? We can help!
Our Insider Programs for pregnancy first-timers will lead you step-by-step through the 14 Pregnancy Must Dos!