PDA

View Full Version : TV & Kids



Duchessa
23-09-2006, 13:03
I've never been very comfortable with my kids watching TV at the age they are. They didn't watch any at all until about 4 months ago (they are 19 months old now) at which point I started letting them watch Playschool 2-3 times a week. That is where we are at now, but I am still not sure I am doing the right thing. I was just reading the article below (from http://www.naturalfamilyonline.com/go/index.php/40/tv-toddlers-and-adhd/#more-40 (http://www.naturalfamilyonline.com/go/index.php/40/tv-toddlers-and-adhd/#more-40%29:)
TV and Your Toddler’s Attention Span (http://www.naturalfamilyonline.com/go/index.php/40/tv-toddlers-and-adhd/)

September 21st, 2006




By Mark Brandenburg
Millions of kids under the age of two are watching TV in this country. In fact, according to a study by the Kaiser Family Foundation of over 1,000 parents, about 65 percent of kids under age two are watching TV, and they’re averaging over two hours of watching a day.
They’re watching even though the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends no TV for kids under age two. They’re watching even though this is a crucial period for their cognitive development, at an age when their brains are still being formed.
The news about these kids just got worse.
Scientists at Children’s Hospital & Regional Medical Center in Seattle, Washington, who studied over 2,500 children, found a link between early TV watching and attention problems at a later age. Specifically, the chances of one- to three-year-old kids developing attention problems at age seven increased by 10 percent for every hour of TV watched each day.
The information from these two studies creates a chilling picture of what’s happening to millions of toddlers in this country. It’s unfair, immoral and unjust, and it needs to be addressed.
Where is the outcry?
But you won’t see an outcry from the mass media giants in this country. You see, we live in the country where “Why TV is Good for Kids” appeared as the cover story in Newsweek Magazine in 2002 — the same Newsweek Magazine that’s owned by the Washington Post Company, which owns a sprawling cable company and six broadcast stations around the country.
No, you won’t hear too much about these important studies from the Time-Warners of the world. Bad for business, you see. But if you’re the parent of a young child, it’s much more than that. It’s the possibility of permanently affecting your child’s health.
There are about nine million children who take prescription medication for ADHD in this country. The number of kids who take ADHD medication has been doubling every two years. And while TV certainly isn’t the culprit in all of these cases, the link between attention problems and TV viewing is too strong to ignore.
The days of the “harmless” argument for TV and kids needs to be put to rest. Parents need to be educated about the very real possibility of causing future attention problems for their kids. And young kids across this country need to be given a fighting chance.
© Mark Brandenburg
Mark Brandenburg, MA, CPCC, CSC, is an author, speaker and certified relationship coach.

Now I know that US TV habits are a bit worse than ours, but ours are getting there... What do the rest of you think/do about TV and your kids? Has it changed depending on their age? Does it worry you at all?

kirstenriley
23-09-2006, 13:34
its an interesting one....my DS is now 20 months. He is allowed to watch wiggles in the morning and in the afternoon(1/2 hour shows). I also let him watch a wiggles or elmo dvd every other day or so too. I think it has some advantages - he actually learns dances and movements and instructions from watching wiggles, the disadvantages are he is now starting to "ask" to watch something which is a bit of a worry.

I would love to see some australian studies on this.

FourAngelKisses
23-09-2006, 14:04
The tv is on all day in our house (we can't get any radio reception and I NEED background noise), but my kids don't watch it. The older 2 will watch Max's Tractor with Matthew after school, and maybe half of a movie before bed, but they don't want to watch anything else, they would rather be outside.
Matthew has the attention span of a housefly, so he will ask to watch his Peter Combe or Teletubbies video, but he will get bored after 30 seconds and go play cars instead.

Funkychicken
23-09-2006, 14:13
We have always been restrictive with the TV in our house. The children have watched some ABC children's shows on and off over the years but until recently we didn't have the TV on until they were in bed. There is absolutely nothing on commercial TV that children NEED to see. They are allowed to watch a rented DVD every few weeks but we try to do this as a family so it isn't just mindless staring. When the movie is over, the TV is turned off. In the last couple of months, I have been letting them stay up on Saturday nights to watch the home video show but the ad's are making me hesitant to keep this as a routine thing.
I once went to a lecture/speaker night and listened to Steve Biddulph (bit of a hero of ours!) and when he finished, he closed then ight with a few comments about children and television. This isn't an exact quote but along these lines-
TV, particularly commercial TV, exists purely to convince everyday people that they are inadequate and that they NEED to go out and buy STUFF to make themselves acceptable and if you aren't out buying this stuff then you are not keeping up with what is important. This pretty much sums up my own opinions on TV also!

Ana Gram
23-09-2006, 14:39
We have the TV on all day, I need the back gorund noise. DD doesn't spend much time actively watching it. She would rather read or paly with her toys.

~rambox~
23-09-2006, 14:42
My Tv is on the Playhouse Disney Channel all Day but my kids are back and forth from that and playing out side. So they spend half the day watching tv and the rest playing outside.

Duchessa
23-09-2006, 14:44
Yeah, FunkyChicken I have to agree with you on just about everything there. We are very fortunate and don't get reception where we will be moving in a couple of months (where dh grew up) so we will be able to control the kids tv consumption very tightly (very happy with this). Both dh's and my own tv consumption was very tightly controled as chldren and I believe we have both benefited from it.

I really like Steve Biddulph's approach to almost everything pertaining to family values etc... TV being one of them :yes:

Rockett
23-09-2006, 15:12
We have the tv on all day when we are home aswell.
Mainly for background noise,but if the Wiggles come on,DD will watch that ,then she'll go back to playing with her toys,and doesn't take much more notice of whats on.

Mamaduke
23-09-2006, 15:24
We have the TV on either Nick Jr or Playhouse Disney - the boys will go back and forth from either watching it or playing outside or in the playroom - because it's always been there it isn't a huge deal for them...I can turn it off and have no reaction whatsoever. They've learnt alot of songs, numbers, letters and even Spanish so I can't see it as a bad thing.
The only commercial TV they watch is Funniest Home Videos on a Saturday night - the ads don't bother me so much, temptation to eat this or buy that is everwhere in life and the sooner they learn they just can't have/eat everything they see the better...I can't keep them in a bubble forever.
Also I don't want them to end up being the sort of kids you see walking past an electrical store or into friend's homes etc and being like a 'deer in the headlights' because there happens to be a TV there that is turned on!

BlessedWithBlue
23-09-2006, 15:28
We have the tv on all day in our house too just mainly for background noise.
My kids watch it all of 10 maybe 15 mins a day, they aren't interested and would rather play outside or play with their toys. I don't think there is anything besides a 5 minute episode a day of Thomas the tank engine that actually interests my ds1 cause he is just obsessed with Thomas the tank.
They would both much rather curl up on the couch with me and read a book.
I do however turn the tv off when i put ds2 down for his nap and ds1 doesn't like having his naps anymore so he will play quietly by himself or help me with various household hcores which he loves to do lol.

jessgray
23-09-2006, 16:56
i think as long as a child isnt watching tv all day and all night its ok. if they go outside and play and stuff then a bit of tv is ok. my ds is watching tv right now he is sick :(

poshBecks
23-09-2006, 17:13
Hmmm something worth thinking about!! :rolleyes: I fear ds watches a bit much t.v.........:o

mum2bubba
23-09-2006, 17:17
Hayley will be 2 in a few weeks and while I don't force her to watch tv she likes things like Sesame Street, Oliie (anything with muppets), Bear in the Big Blue House and The Simpsons. She only sits there for about 5 minutes anyway before she trashes the house :rolleyes: I'd rather have my kids doing other things like drawing or reading books or playing outside using their imaginations.